Brief responses on some miscellaneous matters, including particularly on comments in McInnes et al. FP/PANEL/WP/09 and 9a, and made in his verbal presentation thereof on May 15

Various issues raised in written and verbal arguments about issues to be considered by the penguin Panel are raised. These relate to the reliability of these arguments, and the extent to which results from fishery closures other than off South Africa are to be considered by the Panel.